|
An occasional blog about the mania of Steelers fans across the globe by P-G online sports editor Dan Gigler. Guide to commenting | Terms of Service |

Taking a page from the NHL, it would seem that the NFL is at long last every-so-slightly lifting the lead shield and allowing a little illumination as to how and why they do what they do vis-a-vis legal and illegal hits.
Ed Bouchette passes along this 7 minute video from the NFL featuring Director of Officiating Carl Johnson analyzing replays of hits and explaining what the league is looking for, what some players are doing wrong, and how they can correct it.
For example: illegal = Ryan Clark on Ed Dickson; legal = Adam Jones on Mike Wallace.
Johnson's explanations are thorough and logical, but watching these replays in real-time speed, some of which are 'bang-bang' in nature, you have to imagine that it is an unenviable task in these situations to be the referee, or the defensive player, let alone the guy with the ball getting blown up.
Bottom line: this is the new NFL. An whether you, me, James Harrison or anyone else likes it or doesn't, this is how its going to be moving forward. Players are going to continue to be routinely fined and suspended until these types hits are essentially eradicated from the game.
Also, to illustrate just how much things have changed in the modern NFL and really the unprecedented nature of Harrison's suspension, watch the video below tracked down by Keith Thomas of the great Steel Curtain Rising blog.
It's of Green Bay's Charles Martin bodyslamming the Bears' Jim McMahon, which earned him the last suspension for something that happened during game action between the whistles ... in 1986.

| < Prev | Next > |
|---|
Here are the problems that I see in all this "safety first" talk from the NFL regarding helmet to helmet hits and the disciplines handed out for those hits:
• Using the league's definition, I see helmet to helmet hits on defenseless QB's and receivers every week, which are not called. I understand the "bang bang" nature of the plays, but shouldn't those players be getting fined even if they're not penalized in the game?
• The league needs a uniform standard for punishment. The punishments for these hits seem completely subjective and incongruent. One hit will get fine x dollars while another will get fined y for the basically the same infraction.
James Harrison has received much more negative press for his hits than other players with multiple infractions. Is the league actually going to start suspending other players for similar hits?
If they're taking past offenses into account, are they going to suspend a high profile player like Ray Lewis? He has multiple fines in the past 3 seasons alone for helmet to helmet hits (plus one for kicking another player) and I sincerely doubt he would have been suspended for the hit that Harrison put on McCoy last week.
• The league needs to hold teams accountable for keep players with head injuries out of the game. The Steelers have been great at doing this this season. Hines Ward and Polamalu have been restricted to the sidelines after receiving hits, just to be safe. Whereas, the hit that Harrison got suspended for seemed to obviously affect Colt McCoy's brain in some fashion and yet the coaching staff looked at his hand and rushed him back out there. Maybe the league will do something, but they don't seem to be in any hurry to.
I'm having a hard time seeing why they would take so long to deliberate on what the coaching and training staff did or didn't do, when the result was a player with a head injury (from a suspend-able offense) playing in a game when he shouldn't have.
Overall, the league is inconsistent with the officiating of these hits, with inconsistent punishments, and they seem to penalize players more if the public is complaining loudly enough. The "player safety" smells of a PR move to me, especially coming from a league that has a history of abandoning players after their profitability has ceased.